Rangers Player Grades: Part II
With the Defensemen and Goaltenders already graded, it is time for the 28th ranked New York Ranger Offense to face the music. Again, I am grading the players that were on the playoff roster (with the exception of Anisimov), as Part III of this series will come on Tuesday when I grade players that played a limited role with the Rangers for parts of the season. The players are in alphabetical order, so enjoy and please to comment.
Center:
- #15 - Blair Betts (Age: 29) - Grade: B
I can hear you guys now; "A B for Betts? Are you insane...?" Possibly, but let me explain. Betts has always been destined to be a checking line center, and that is what he was for the Rangers this season and it is what he has been his whole NHL career. The fact of the matter is that Betts did his job this season, and he did it well. He won nearly 50% of his face-offs (which doesn't sound impressive, but it is), and was a rock on the Penalty Kill. Oh, and don't forget about him blocking shots, either. He is a UFA this summer, and I hope the Rangers bring him back because you need role players like Betts to win hockey games.
- #23 - Chris Drury (Age: 32) - Grade: B-
Drury's point total dropped for the fourth season in a row to 56, along with his goal total to 22. Still, he was third on the team in scoring, and won over 55% of his face-offs for the season. I'm sure Drury is disappointed in his point totals dropping as well, but I think it isn't necessarily a bad thing. Drury has gotten even better at face-offs than he has been in the past, and he does a lot of little things right that win hockey games. Drury could easily be one of the players to heavily benefit from a new and aggressive system, as he reads the game well and capitalizes on other teams' mistakes.
- #17 - Brandon Dubinsky (Age: 23) - Grade: B
One of the best forwards for his age and role on the Rangers all season, hands down. He tallied 13 goals and 28 assists for a 1 point improvement over last season to 41 points. He upped his shots on goal by over 30, and went from 0 Game-Winners last season to 7 this season. Next season could be huge for Dubinsky, who if he matures a little more in his body could be doing what he did in playoffs all season. He needs to watch the amount of time he spends in the box though, as he takes unnecessary penalties sometimes.
- #19 - Scott Gomez (Age: 29) - Grade: B-
The funny thing with Gomez is that all of us Ranger fans know he's got great speed and hands to dish the puck around, but we get mad when he's not scoring goals or creating chances. Gomez is a playmaker, there is no doubt about that, but this year without Jagr on his line his stats are kind of a microcosm of the Rangers season if you ask me. Gomez had the same amount of goals (16) as last season, but dropped 12 assists to 42 total points. Without guys who can bury the puck, Gomez can't be himself. Another telling stat is that he took the most shots of his career this past season, almost 30 more than any other season in the NHL. Once again, Gomez is in the group of talented Ranger forwards that could easily benefit from a more aggressive offensive plan; which we all hope to see.
Right Wing:
- #80 - Nik Antropov (Age: 29) - Grade: C+
Antropov had his best season in the NHL, tallying 28 goals and 31 helpers for 59 points, a 3 point improvement from last season. Seven goals and 13 of those points came with the Rangers, to which he provided a little bit of a scoring spark to. Antropov only gets a C+ in my book because I watched him on Toronto plenty of times (Getting CBC in Central NY), and he seemed more aggressive there. I don't blame this all on him seeing the system he was playing in here in NY, but at the same time I thought we might see a couple of end to end rushes when I heard the Rangers had traded for him. Either way, Antropov is a UFA and it will be interesting to see if the Rangers bring him back. I personally would let him walk, as it clears nearly $2 million in cap and he isn't my style of player because he doesn't use his natural size that he is blessed with. But we all know Sather is in love with giant forwards, so we will see.
- #24 - Ryan Callahan (Age: 24) - Grade: B+
In his second full season with the Rangers Callahan made a huge impact. Arguably the best forward on the club all season, he netted 22 goals and added 18 helpers for 40 points, and ended up with a +7 rating. He had over 230 shots, and still did great in his own end blocking shots as well. There isn't much else I can say about Callahan, who really just stood out in a group of forwards that struggled all season. He is an RFA going into the summer, and I really hope Sather has enough cash to keep Cally, otherwise you will see a Ranger uprising in response.
- #29 - Colton Orr (Age: 27) - Grade: C+
I personally thought Colton Orr improved a lot this season from last. His skating is better, and he even improved his fighting record (according to the voters at Hockeyfights.com) from 10 to 12 wins out of 18 fights (same as last season). He had 1 goal and 4 assists for 5 points, his career high. The fact of the matter is Orr does his job and if he improves his skating again he isn't such a liability on the ice. If he can do that and take less unnecessary penalties when the fourth line is out there, Orr could be a key part to a winning Ranger team in 2009-2010 if he decides to re-sign.
- #13 - Nikolai Zherdev (Age 24) - Grade: B
Nokalai Zherdev will be a hot topic for weeks to come. He tied for the team lead in points with 58, scoring 23 goals and adding 35 assists. He was one of the few Ranger forwards to have a plus rating, coming in at +6. He had over a 10% shot percentage, and overall brought what was promised to Broadway. Zherdev will be a hot topic because of his lack of scoring in this year's playoffs along with the fact that many think he dogs shifts during points of the season. While both are true if you ask me, imagine what Zherdev could do on an offensive team if he led in points on the 28th ranked offense in the NHL. I could see him pushing 80 points, easily, if the Rangers go into the top 20 or 15 in scoring next season.
Left Wing:
- #16 - Sean Avery (Age: 29) - Grade: B-
Avery will play his first full season with the Rangers starting next fall since 2007-2008 when he netted 33 points in 57 games. In his 18 games with the Rangers in 2009, he had 12 points; 5 of which were goals and 2 of those on the Power-Play. Everyone knows the Rangers record is ridiculously better with Sean in the lineup, so next season will be interesting. He and coach John Tortorella have spoken out and said they are comfortable with each other and look forward to next season, which is great as long as it holds true. I thought Avery did his job this season; and although he hurt the Rangers a couple of times with stupid penalties he is still an asset who the Rangers need to set the pace night in and night out.
- #29 - Lauri Korpikoski (Age: 22) - Grade: C+
Korpikoski had the typical adjustment season any above-average NHL prospect has in his first season. The key will be can he bounce back and really show his skills next season. He will need to add some size along with a craving to go the net, which he rarely showed if you ask me. He had 6 goals and 8 assists for 14 points in 68 games this past season, which I somewhat expected. He also added 2 assists in the playoffs, which is a good sign. He should be back next season (RFA), and as long as he adds some size for 2009, we could see Korpikoski have a Dubinsky-esque season with 40 points or so.
- #91 - Markus Naslund (Age: 35) - Grade: C+
Fifteen seasons, almost 900 points, 395 of which were goals. He netted 46 points in his one season with the Rangers, 24 of which were goals and adding another 22 assists to his impressive resume. Many were hoping for a Broadway revival of the old Markus who could put up 70 points easily, but it just didn't happen. He did what he could in such a defensive system, but because he didn't really click with Gomez there wasn't really anyone that could get him the puck on a consistent basis. Sure, we lose an automatic 15 goals and 30 points next season with his retirement, but he clears some cap space for Sather to make up for some of his mistakes. Naslund has a great shot and I will miss some of the great ones that went in so beautifully next season.
- #20 - Fredrik Sjostrom (Age: 25) - Grade: B
Playing in a fourth line role, Sjostrom struggled with scoring with only 13 points, but he managed 7 of those to be goals, most of which were ugly and hard working. I like Sjostrom, he has great speed and size, and has great defensive instincts. If he could work on his hands over the next season or so, he could reach the 20 point plateau in a third line role. He did great work in the playoffs blocking shots, and as an RFA could be back for another season of the same.
- #34 - Aaron Voros (Age: 27) - Grade: D+
Giving Aaron Voros $1.2 million last season was another head-scratcher from Glen Sather, but he came out of the gate flying in 2008. Unfortunately, this would not last as Voros would play very little in the second half, and almost not at all under new coach John Tortorella. Voros has spent a lot of his career in the minors, and one of his biggest problem is playing consistently well in the NHL. Scoring so much early did not help expectations of him, because he couldn't keep a point per game pace for long, and he dropped off the depth chart for the Rangers. He will be back next season, and if he could find his game more next season, he could reach over 20 points and have a place on a Ranger offense that could use his size and physical play in a third or fourth line role.
So there is Part II of the Ranger grades. One thing I want everyone to keep in mind is that I grade each player by their role on the team, not necessarily who is "better." Of course I think Dubinsky (B) is better than Betts (also a B). But the fact of the matter is that both play different roles on the team, and both did their jobs well I thought this season. Part III will be coming tomorrow, as we examine those who chipped in a little over the 2008-2009 Ranger season, including those that were traded away at the deadline. Have at it in the comments.
0 recs |
23 comments
|
Comments
the only one I would strongly disagree with you on is Zherdev, I wouldn’t grade him any higher than a C. If the Rangers re-sign him, I would love to see him on a line with Anisimov next year
Blueshirt Banter: Covering the New York Rangers
Big Blue View: Unofficial New York Giants blog
by Jim Schmiedeberg on May 4, 2009 10:24 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
theres two theories of thought when it comes to Z
(1) can the rangers afford to gamble on the 24 year old with a long term contract @ 3 to 4 million
(2) the rangers can’t afford NOT to gamble on him because they are so severely deprived of goal scoring. especially b/c of the passing of cherepanov.
by Ryan McFadden on May 4, 2009 11:11 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
yes, and yes.
this time around. when we have the talent this young. i’d rather see him sink with us then soar with others.
by #17ToTheRafters on May 4, 2009 11:46 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Oh hey Jim!
Welcome back! Don’t ever go to the View again … You’re ours!
The Ranger Reporter - My Ranger Blog!
by Joe Fortunato on May 4, 2009 12:19 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
I have to moonlight at the View, they need my special brand of humor, LOL
Blueshirt Banter: Covering the New York Rangers
Big Blue View: Unofficial New York Giants blog
by Jim Schmiedeberg on May 4, 2009 1:02 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Well we get jealous all over here
so no more!
The Ranger Reporter - My Ranger Blog!
by Joe Fortunato on May 4, 2009 1:21 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Age
What is so impressive looking at this list is that, with the retirement of Naslund, we’ll only have a handful of players over thirty, with the rest (hopefully) ready to bust under Torts. It’s really pretty awesome.
by DC Ranger on May 4, 2009 2:21 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
not thrilled with this easy grading system
I just have to say you were really soft on this bunch of underachieving fowards.
but i digress. i want to talk about nik zherdev
i agree with the manic ranger when he says the cant afford to spend a long term contract on him, but then again then cant afford not to. Zherdev is a pretty sick player, but he played for the first month of the season, then disappeared for the last 60 games.
i think the key in the nhl right now is to get YOUNG. i love gomez, and i like what drury represents, but its time to move to a FULL youth movement.
Suck a year or two with your youth, then get a few top 10 draft picks and BAM, instant success in the new NHL. signing a NHL vet here and there, and then you become the penguins.
by ImaMoose on May 4, 2009 5:35 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
easier said than done.
not only that, but when you have the choice to draft Crosby or Malkin, it makes the drafting process really easy. not very impressive what the Penguins did. actually, not impressive at all.
by Ryan McFadden on May 4, 2009 6:22 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
TMR said it best, easier said than done. You can’t just trade or buyout some of these contracts, they are too big. You have to re-tool around these guys.
And the grading system is based on past seasons (go look for yourself, no body on the Rangers roster is really a 100 point man), and my expectations. I knew going into this year that most Ranger fans had over-rated their team, especially the offense, so I guess that explains why I’m giving out B’s.
Along with this, you have to remember this team made the playoffs – something 7 other teams in the Eastern Conference couldn’t do…
by Rob Luker on May 4, 2009 7:51 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Grade Changes
Dubinsky – poor regular season better play-offs grade is too high. Zherdev based on disappearing in the playoffs must be down graded as well. Mara is a human tripod and I would give him a C-, Lundquist and Valiquette cannot have the same grade if they flip flopped roles Valiquette would be exposed.
by Petey Dee on May 4, 2009 6:22 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Mara
mara does not deserve a C-. saying he is a human tripod is exaggerating. not only that he’s a great team player and a key to that locker room.
by Ryan McFadden on May 4, 2009 6:24 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Dubinsky did not have a poor regular season, you have to look beyond the scoresheet. He’s never going to be a 30 goal scorer, but he works hard every night, is one of the Rangers better penalty killers, and I’ve never seen him take a shift off
Blueshirt Banter: Covering the New York Rangers
Big Blue View: Unofficial New York Giants blog
by Jim Schmiedeberg on May 4, 2009 8:07 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I agree with jrs, Zherdev gets a C in my mind, he did on my blog too. :)
My Rangers Blog: http://rangerstribune.com/
by NYRBlogger on May 4, 2009 8:49 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Ludicrous
That is the only way I can describe these grades. I guess you watched the team with rose coloured glasses or something. How you gave the huge letdowns that were Gomez and Drury got the same grade as Sean Avery is beyond me. But then again, not a single F or an A … I mean, I know this stuff is arbitrary but you can look at this team and say that not a single player played as good as they possibly could or one was an absolute disappointment? Geez.
I have a blog too! www.scottyhockey.com
Let's Go Rangers!
by Scotty Hockey on May 4, 2009 10:50 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Actually
Ludicrous would be signing a guy for more than he’s worth, and expecting better results because you overpaid him. Scott Gomez’s numbers this season were in line with the rest of his career. Blaming Gomez for the Rangers not having sufficient scoring around him is ludicrous. Same goes for Drury. As far as Aaron Voros, not sure what you guys expected from him either, but he had 2 more points in one less game for the Rangers than he did for the Wild the year before. So at this rate, by 2040 he’ll be playing 20 games and have 60 points.
Ludicrous is in the eyes of the beholder.
Blueshirt Banter: Covering the New York Rangers
Big Blue View: Unofficial New York Giants blog
by Jim Schmiedeberg on May 5, 2009 10:47 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Grade Inflation
Is alive and well in this country. Otherwise, Voros would get an ‘F’ (he really did not live up to anyone’s expectations, including his own). Drury has a ‘C’ season, as did Naslund and Gomez. But we bump everyone up, compress the grades and voila, no one’s feelings get hurt. Try doing your grading with a real bell curve and see where the chips fall.
As for Z, the Rangers should lock him up long-term. He’s demonstrated that he’s a talent. Only problem is that Torts treated him pretty poorly and he crumbled in the playoffs. Not the only player who crumbled, but if he’s not back its because of a personality clash with the coach and had nothing to do with his skill and potential.
by Blueshirts Rock on May 4, 2009 11:07 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
What kind of expectations did you have for him?
He put up the kinds of numebrs we all expected.
The Ranger Reporter - My Ranger Blog!
by Joe Fortunato on May 5, 2009 12:24 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I disagree because I predicted a seventh place finish. I just expected these guys to play to their potential and suck. Not lollygag and collect paychecks.
I have a blog too! www.scottyhockey.com
Let's Go Rangers!
by Scotty Hockey on May 5, 2009 2:29 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I'm Confused...
If you predicted them at seventh, and on your site your explanation was “King Henrik Reigns supreme” then what exactly did you expect everyone else to do?
If Gomez, Drury, and anyone else your upset with all had career years, we would have never dropped from first in the eastern conference all year…
by Rob Luker on May 5, 2009 2:40 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
If I were to say
“a B for Betts, are you insane?” it would be because he deserves a higher grade than that. Penalty killing was the best thing the Rangers did all season and he was a massive contributor to that success. No, he doesn’t have Drury’s offensive skill, but he’s also paid less than 10% of what Drury is.
by JoshNY on May 6, 2009 11:51 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Betts
has got to be one of th Rangers top priorities this offseason. I hope no one tries to outbid for him, but the Ranger need to do what they can to retain him.
I’d think the Rangers know about their penalty kill and how BB is probably their best guy on that unit.
by FreeBradshaw on May 6, 2009 4:58 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs

by 






























