New York Rangers Traverse City Tournament: Final Analysis Edition
The Traverse City Tournament has come and gone, with the New York Rangers' prospects falling in the championship game to the Buffalo Sabres' prospects. But that doesn't mean the tournament was all bad.
We got a good look at some of the up-and-coming players within the Rangers' farm system, including an opportunity to see this year's first-round draft pick, J.T. Miller, extensively. We also got to look at a few players, Christian Thomas and Tim Erixon specifically, who are expected to make a push for a roster spot once training camp opens up.
So who stepped up? Who dropped the ball? Find out, after the jump.
Christian Thomas: Thomas came into this tournament trying to prove that he is ready for a roster spot with the big club this season. Although Thomas only notched a goal and two assists in four games, he was dangerous on every shift. Countless passes were completed by Thomas in dangerous areas of the ice, only for his line mates to miss potential goals. And while Thomas flaunted his vision all tournament, it took him three games before he really started to shoot the puck. Once he did start ripping shots, you could see right away why scouts fell in love with him. Overall, this was a good series of games for Thomas, who proved he has all the skills necessary to become an NHL player. He's going to get a long, hard look in camp, and he deserves it after his performance at Traverse City.
Tim Erixon: Another play who entered the tournament trying to prove he's ready for a spot with the Rangers out of camp, Erixon did everything and anything anyone could have possibly expected from him. Erixon was brilliant on the power play, he was solid in his own zone and he transitioned the puck like a veteran. It should be noted that Erixon is the only player on the Rangers Traverse City roster with significant (or any) SEL experience, which made this tournament a little easier for him than other prospects. But if that's the case then you would expect Erixon to dominate, and I think he did. Sure his offensive numbers could have been better, but the team was always dangerous when he was on the ice. Remember that the Ranges' organization is very high on the young defenseman, so I really expect him to stick with the big club this year out of camp.
Carl Hagelin: The Swedish forward entered play after a career year in the NCAA with the Michigan Wolverines, and was said to have quick hands and a nifty shot. Well, he showed off both during the tournament. If Hagelin hadn't opened your eyes before this tournament, they're probably open now. He showed off his speed, his shot and his vision all tournament. And while I still don't think he's ready for the NHL just yet, he's getting there.
J.T. Miller: Miller was watched very closely this tournament, mainly because there are people who believed other players should have been drafted instead of him. Although Miller had a pretty bad outing his first game, I think he got better as the tournament went on, and was great in the final game. I thought Miller truly showed what he could bring to the table in the championship game, making a difference almost everywhere he went. He scored a goal, threw out a few great passes and hit everything that moved. His overall game is what drew the Rangers to him, and he showed it in flashes during Traverse City. Now it's time for him to find consistency, but for his first tournament, I loved what I saw from him.
Note: Due to an early day at work, I could only analyze a few of the bigger names below. Tomorrow will include the rest of the pack. Tomorrow's post will include Ryan Bourque, Dylan McIlrath and all the rest.
14 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Thanks for the great analysis, Joe!
I haven’t been able to watch all of the games, so the in depth analysis certainly helps keep me abreast of the competitions that will be held during training camp…I, like many other Broadway fanatics, have waited along time for our youth movement to develop, and am extremely excited about being a consistently good team for years to come!
I think you should at least have given a few words on Bourque’s behalf. Granted it was a small sample-size, but he was definitely one of the best forwards on the team, and displayed some good hockey-sense in knowing where to be (was also used as a top penalty killer) to go with some great wheels and some tenacity. Granted Hagelin and arguably Miller have higher ceilings, but that Bourque kid is going to find himself a spot on somebody’s team.
Looking at Erixon’s play, I think he has the ability to come to the Rangers and be what Wade Redden was supposed to be, which is a good 2-way defender that can help run a power-play from the point. Obviously Erixon’s game is based on his ability to quickly process the game and make quick, quality decisions, which should help the power-play. He should also see a much more gradual increase in defensive workload since we have the Staal/Girardi and McDonagh/Sauer pairings to eat up minutes. Looking at the mistake they made with Del Zotto, hopefully they’ll bring Erixon along slowly and allow him to find his way, especially on the defensive side.
Blueshirt Banter *It's just pain.*
R.I.P. Derek 'Boogeyman' Boogaard
Did you miss the bottom of the post?
:)
Blueshirt Banter: Covering the New York Rangers the only NHL team with three home arenas.
"We can trade Lisin for a gun, then hold it to Drury’s head and make him waive the no-movement clause" - XLII
"Tortorelli sounds like a kind of pasta… an unforgiving, stubborn, chewy, flavorless pasta that demands ‘jam’ from other pastas." - Dig Deep
by Joe Fortunato on Sep 15, 2011 4:06 PM EDT up reply actions
Damnit, was reading it from my phone and the italic font was barely visible and I skipped over it. My apologies :-\
Blueshirt Banter *It's just pain.*
R.I.P. Derek 'Boogeyman' Boogaard
Don't feel too bad.
I missed it too and was about to post something similar. Bourque may not have the offensive ceiling of a Thomas or a Miller, but I think he will be a valuable 3rd liner/penalty killer/potential leader, which is not a bad return on a 3rd round pick.
Others that stood out...
for me personally were
Bourque
McCoulgan (Spelling)
Audy-Marchaunt (Again Spelling)
Mainly because I have heard little about them until this tournament.
Side Note: I’m sure I echo everyone here’s sentiments when I say I really REALLY enjoyed watching this tournament. I hope it becomes a staple on MSG for years to come.
+1
"Mr. Madison, what you've just said is one of the most insanely idiotic things I have ever heard. At no point in your rambling, incoherent response were you even close to anything that could be considered a rational thought. Everyone in this room is now dumber for having listened to it. I award you no points, and may God have mercy on your soul."
LET'S GO RANGERS!!!
After watching all of the games, with extensive DVR use of pauses and replays, I’ll make the following comments:
1 – Erixon is not ready for regular NHL duty. He’s going to need time to adjust to the smaller rink, and does not have the strength necessary to battle in the corners. He may well be ready by mid-season – he may even make the team as 7th D (which would be a mistake – he needs regular playing time to make the move). Unless DelZotto bombs, Erixon starts in WhalePack land.
2 – Thomas – nearly the same as the above – although he plays a different position. Needs to get much stronger. He’s going to be a ton of fun to watch when he makes it, though.
3 – Hagelin – because he’s older – he doesn’t need as much strength build-out as the above. I think he’ll stand a better chance to make the roster than Thomas – but still think he’s also Connecticut bound.
4 – Miller – Future Cally/Dubi with more goal scoring capability. As he fills out/grows up, he’s going to be impressive. Still a lot to learn ( holds on to the puck too long at times) – but doesn’t have all that far to go. Should be fun to see him at the tournament next year – as a gaudy 19 year old….
5 – Bourque – his shot and scoring ability are much better than I thought. He’s relentless (another Cally type), will hit anything moving or not, and has fantastic vision and skating. Depending on who needs to be replaced due to injury, I could see him being a first or second call up.
6 – McIlrath – has made huge strides since last year. Much better skating. Some offensive ability (made some nice passes early in the tourney). Needs to not worry about retaliation – took a few too many senseless penalties – following guys around to “get even” which led to goals-against. Another year and he should be very close to NHL ready.
Audy-Marchessault – what a great signing of an undrafted free agent. Whether there will be a spot for him in a year or so is open to question, but I can see him on an NHL roster someday in the future.
McColgan – another with lots of speed. Very raw and has lots of room to learn and grow – but if he continues to develop will be another one to watch.
Having said all that – things can change during the NHL Ranger’s Camp. We’ll see what happens…..
Largely agree.
The fawning over Erixon is unwarranted and you pointed out the obvious. He is rail thin and I have doubts if he will look as effective in preseason. He’s going to eventually be ready and become a solid contributor, but the beat off session needs to end.
Miller has me interested. If he progresses over next two to three years and doesn’t plateau, he could be a Dubinsky type. The only thing that stuck out was his skating, he looked stiff legged. Not slow, just rigid.
Bourque, I want to say he could be a Callahan type but he might be destined for Nigel Dawes territory. 60 point AHL player that can’t transition to NHL. That’s the only thing tempering my enthusiasm. I can’t wait to see him in preseason and in CT.
Hagelin has me excited. I think he’ll get top line and special teams minutes in CT. Possible 2nd half call up IMO for bottom six depth. Will be great replacement for Avery next year.
Audi Marshmellow looks like another PA Pap Smear.
by Gabby the Gutless Sniper on Sep 15, 2011 6:25 PM EDT via mobile up reply actions
Difference between Dawes and Bourque...
Bourque has much better defensive ability and is much more willing to hit (even though he is small). Since Bourque will probably never be a big scorer in the NHL, defense is key to his value. Solid D plus decent playmaking and a little goal scoring can make for a fine NHL career.
The best thing is that when guys like Avery, Feds, Wolski, and Christensen are done here, we will have plenty of guys to take their place.
"Mr. Madison, what you've just said is one of the most insanely idiotic things I have ever heard. At no point in your rambling, incoherent response were you even close to anything that could be considered a rational thought. Everyone in this room is now dumber for having listened to it. I award you no points, and may God have mercy on your soul."
LET'S GO RANGERS!!!
Kreider or Yogan?
…or both? :P I assume you’re talking about Kreider, but Yogan isn’t someone to scoff at. For a fourth-round pick, he could certainly be a steal.

by 


























